Forensic Evidence and the Right to a Fair Trial in Pakistan: Admissibility, Reliability, and Justice

Contributors

  • Dr. Syed Murad Ali Shah Head of the Department of Law, The University of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, Pakistan.
  • Muhammad Usman Riaz Gill Advocate Supreme Court of Pakistan; Partner, Marlin, Peregrine & Usman (LLP), Advocates, Solicitors & Legal Consultants, Pakistan.
  • Umar Farooq Lecturer, Rasul College of Law, University of Rasul, Mandi Bahauddin, Pakistan.
  • Shoket Ali PhD Research Scholar (International Relations), Institute of International Relations, Shah Abdul Latif University, Khairpur, Pakistan.
  • Dr. Rabia Razzaq Assistant Professor, University Law College, University of the Punjab, Lahore, Punjab, Pakistan.
Keywords
Forensic Evidence Article 10-A Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984 DNA Fair Trial Pakistan

Abstract

DNA, digital evidence, ballistic evidence and toxicological evidence are increasingly used in criminal courts in Pakistan to solve cases. This paper suggests that this change invigorates the right to a fair trial under Article 10-A of the Constitution only if the forensic evidence is adduced in a manner that is transparent, is obtained from reputable, accredited laboratories and can be subject to genuine testing by the accused. This relies on statute, dominant decisions and Pakistani statistics to conclude that the law on admissibility has outstripped the institutions which create and review forensic evidence. In 2022, DNA cases in Punjab got stuck halfway as half of the cases were pending without reference samples, while in KP, 83,000 samples were pending in 2025 and in the country, the rate of rape conviction stood at approximately 0.5 per cent in 2024. In an original study of 2024 Sindh High Court appeals, the study reveals that in just 11 of the 15 merits decisions, the forensic evidence introduced at the trial was discarded for some procedural reason, and never due to the science. The paper also covers the Islamic law, the objection that more stringent rules would reduce convictions, and recommended prioritised changes.

References

Ali Accountability Lab Pakistan. (n.d.). Why are sexual violence cases rising while convictions remain so low in Pakistan?

Ahmad, I., & Bakhsh, F. (2024). Emerging developments in DNA technology and their potential implications for the criminal justice system of Pakistan. Current Trends in Law and Society.

Ali, Y. (2025, December 2). 83,000 forensic samples pending in K-P because of severe staff shortages. The Express Tribune.

Ali Haider alias Pappu v. Jameel Hussain, PLD 2021 SC 362 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, Criminal Petition No. 513 of 2020, January 7, 2021).

Asghar, M. (2020, January 9). PFSA tells Punjab police to submit DNA samples after thorough investigation. Dawn.

Associated Press of Pakistan. (2025, November 20). SC acquits 2 men in double murder case.

Associated Press of Pakistan. (2026a, January 20). Death sentence converted to life imprisonment in murder case.

Associated Press of Pakistan. (2026b, June 1). KP decides establishing forensic science laboratory costing Rs20 bln.

Atif Zareef v. The State, PLD 2021 SC 550 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, Criminal Appeal No. 251 of 2020, January 4, 2021).

Azeem Khan v. Mujahid Khan, 2016 SCMR 274 (2016).

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, § 176(3) (India).

Bingham, C. (2020, February). The Punjab Forensic Science Agency: Building a model agency from the ground up. The ISHI Report. Promega.

Butt, A. M. (2023, November 9). Punjab forensic lab withholds details of tests. The News.

Chairman NAB v. Nasar Ullah, Civil Petitions Nos. 1809–1814 of 2020 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, April 19, 2022).

Cheema, S. A. (2016). DNA evidence in Pakistani courts: An analysis. LUMS Law Journal, 3(1), 1.

Cheema, S. A. (2019). Corroborating evidence as a mechanism to fill “reliability void” in Pakistan’s criminal justice system: Judicial discretion and its limitations. Pakistan Journal of Criminology, 11(4), 55.

Cheema, S. A., & Khan, S. O. (2022). Expert opinion under the Pakistani legal system: An analytical study of its evidential value. Law and Policy Review, 1(2).

Chishti, A. J. (2023, July 25). Centre withdraws DNA Technology Regulation Bill 2019 from Lok Sabha. LiveLaw.

CII rules out DNA as primary evidence in rape cases. (2013, September 23). Dawn.

Crown Prosecution Service. (n.d.). Forensic Science Regulator Act 2021 and the Forensic Science Regulator’s Code of Practice 2023 [Legal guidance].

Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals, Inc., 509 U.S. 579 (1993).

Dror, I. E., & Hampikian, G. (2011). Subjectivity and bias in forensic DNA mixture interpretation. Science & Justice, 51(4), 204–208. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.scijus.2011.08.004

Equality Now. (2026). Rape survivors in Pakistan struggle to access justice despite legal reforms, new report finds.

Farooq, U., & Shahzad, M. (2018, February 6). Asma’s murder: DNA sample matches with one of the suspects. The Express Tribune.

Federation of Pakistan v. Justice (R) Jawwad S. Khawaja, Intra-Court Appeal No. 5 of 2023 (Supreme Court of Pakistan, Constitutional Bench, May 7, 2025).

Foundation for Fundamental Rights & Reprieve. (2019). The Pakistan capital punishment study.

Garrett, B. L., & Neufeld, P. J. (2009). Invalid forensic science testimony and wrongful convictions. Virginia Law Review, 95(1), 1–97.

High Court of Sindh. (n.d.). Caselaw for Sindh High Court [Public reports: Category-wise lists of judgments].

How effective are new amendments to anti-rape laws. (2025). Lok Sujag.

Ijaz, R. M. (2024, August 19). SC suspends IHC verdict in audio leaks case. ARY News.

An inhumane justice system. (2019, April). Dawn.

Iqbal, N. (2021, April 5). Cases decided on basis of evidence, not emotions: SC. Dawn.

Ishtiaq Ahmed Mirza v. Federation of Pakistan, PLD 2019 SC 675 (2019).

Judiciary is a means to an end. (2024). The Express Tribune.

Justice (R) Jawwad S. Khawaja v. Federation of Pakistan, PLD 2024 SC 337 (2024).

Kainat Soomro v. Province of Sindh, PLD 2020 Sindh 611 (2020); order of June 4, 2021, in CP No. D-5920 of 2015, 2021 SHC KHI 984 (Sindh High Court, 2021).

Kamal Din alias Kamala v. The State, 2018 SCMR 577 (2018).

Kassin, S. M., Dror, I. E., & Kukucka, J. (2013). The forensic confirmation bias: Problems, perspectives, and proposed solutions. Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 2(1), 42–52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jarmac.2013.01.001

Taylor & Francis Online

KMC forensic medicine dept wants govt nod to funds utilisation. (2023, February). Dawn.

Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan. (2024). 3rd bi-annual report: January to June 2024.

Law Commission. (2011). Expert evidence in criminal proceedings in England and Wales (Law Com No. 325).

Legal Aid Society. (2023). Assessing the implementation of DNA standard operating procedures by the Sindh Police Department.

LHC upholds death penalty for convict in Zainab murder case. (2018, March 21). Dawn.

Majid alias Dodo v. The State, Special Anti-Terrorism Jail Appeal No. D-175 of 2019 (Sindh High Court, Sukkur Bench, April 18, 2024).

Malik, H. (2025, May 8). SC greenlights military trials of civilians. The Express Tribune.

Mantovanelli v. France, (1997) 24 EHRR 370.

Ministry of Law and Justice. (2023). Anti-Rape (Crisis Cell and Medico-Legal) Rules 2022 and Anti-Rape (Investigation) Rules 2022 (SRO 185(I)/2023).

Momand, A. (2024, May 3). Govt notifies new cybercrime investigation agency to tackle Peca offences. Dawn.

Muhammad Abid Hussain v. The State, 2025 SCMR 721 (2025).

Muhammad Shahid Sahil v. The State, PLD 2010 FSC 215 (2010).

Murderer, rapist of six-year-old girl hanged in Pakistan. (2018, October 17). Arab News.

National Commission for Human Rights, National Academy of Prison Administration, & Justice Project Pakistan. (2025). Prison data report 2024. As reported in “Overcrowding endemic in Pakistan’s prison system: Report,” Dawn, 2025.

National Research Council. (2009). Strengthening forensic science in the United States: A path forward. National Academies Press. https://doi.org/10.17226/12589

Naveed Asghar v. The State, PLD 2021 SC 600 (2021).

Nawab Siraj Ali v. The State, 2023 SCMR 16 (2023).

Planning and Development Department, Government of Balochistan. (2024, October 1). PDWP reviews establishment of Forensic Science Laboratory in Quetta under Prosecution Department.

President’s Council of Advisors on Science and Technology. (2016). Forensic science in criminal courts: Ensuring scientific validity of feature-comparison methods. Executive Office of the President.

Punjab Forensic Science Agency. (2023). Annual performance report 2022.

Salman Akram Raja v. Government of Punjab, 2013 SCMR 203 (2013).

SC seeks clarity on DNA evidence in rape conviction. (2026). The Express Tribune.

SFDL-ICCBS solves 8,000 DNA and serology cases. (2025, September). Bol News.

Suo Motu Case No. 4 of 2010 (contempt proceedings against Prime Minister Syed Yousaf Raza Gillani), PLD 2012 SC 553 (2012).

Sustainable Social Development Organization. (2025). Mapping gender-based violence in Pakistan 2024. As reported in “Conviction rates critically low in gender-based violence cases: Report,” Dawn, March 1, 2025.

United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime. (2024, February). EU project boosts forensic lab in Quetta: Strengthening crime investigation.

Yasif, R. (2018, October 12). Zainab murder case: Imran Ali to be executed on Oct 17. The Express Tribune.

Yousafzai, A. (2024, May 30). Audio leaks case: IHC restrains telecom companies from tapping phones for surveillance. The News.

Zahid Sarfaraz Gill v. The State, 2024 SCMR 934 (2024). See also Farhan, M. (2024). Case note. LUMS SAHSOL.

Zainab’s rapist, murderer Imran Ali hanged at Kot Lakhpat Jail. (2018, October 17). Dawn.

Zia, M. H., Akhtar, M. S., & Hassan, H. (2021). Legal assessment of DNA evidence in Pakistan. Journal of Development and Social Sciences, 2(3), 391–400. https://doi.org/10.47205/jdss.2021(2-III)33

Corresponding Author

Dr. Syed Murad Ali Shah

Head of the Department of Law, The University of Azad Jammu and Kashmir, Pakistan.

Corresponding Author: [email protected]

How to Cite

Shah, S. M. A., Gill, M. U. R., Farooq, U., Ali, S., & Razzaq, R. (2026). Forensic Evidence and the Right to a Fair Trial in Pakistan: Admissibility, Reliability, and Justice. The Regional Tribune, 5(10), 72-90. https://doi.org/10.55737/trt/v-x.499